Marjorie's pick · Updated September 2026
Spenco Polysorb Cross Trainer Athletic Cushioning Arch Support Shoe

For someone who wants more cushioning or arch support from a pair of everyday trainers, these insoles are the kind of add-in worth considering. They are aimed at athletic shoes, but the real question is fit: whether your shoes have enough room for an aftermarket insole, whether the arch shape matches your foot, and whether you want a softer step without changing the shoes themselves.
A product like this makes the most sense when a shoe is close to right but not quite enough on its own. People who stand a lot, walk a lot, train in sneakers, or want to give a worn pair a little more support may all look at this style of insert before replacing the shoes. The size range matters here too, because a better fit will usually depend on trimming or choosing the correct size band, and that is something to confirm before ordering. Arch support is not one-size-fits-all, and a shape that feels helpful to one person can feel too pronounced to another.
The main thing to verify is shoe volume. Some athletic insoles take up more space than buyers expect, especially in snug running shoes or shoes with a low toe box. It is also worth checking whether the original factory insole comes out cleanly, since many replacement inserts work best when they fully replace the stock liner rather than stacking on top of it. That small detail can change how the shoe fits at the heel and forefoot.
The listing points to cushioning and arch support as the main reasons to consider it, which is the right place to start. Cushioning can help spread pressure more evenly, and arch support can matter if a shoe feels flat or tiring over the course of a day. But the right level of support is personal, so it helps to compare the shape of the insole with the kind of arch you usually get on with. If you prefer a very low-profile insert, or if your current shoes already feel tight, that is a sign to slow down and measure first.
This is the kind of purchase that rewards practical checking more than hype. Look at the shoe type, the amount of room you have, and whether you want a cushioned feel or a firmer support profile. If those line up, this may be a sensible way to improve a pair of shoes you already like without replacing the whole shoe. If they do not, a different insole shape may be the better fit.
Some Amazon links are affiliate links. Marjorie may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
See current price